It might not make sense.. I put Max down as my public crush and it won't show up on his, so the thing doesn't appear to be working correctly to begin with.

In any case I don't think it should be used as a judge of character anyway, it certainly doesn't mean you're not crush-worthy. (I felt a bit weird about putting some people I don't know very well down as crushes, especially if there was a chance that I might meet them in the future).